Willyn Villarica Jewelry

A Guide to Assessing the Value of Vintage Jewelry

Vintage jewelry holds an undeniable sense of charm and allure – it’s no surprise that they are beloved by so many! There are several reasons why people love vintage pieces, the first being their timelessness. Vintage jewelry always stays in style and can be seen as a reflection of personal taste rather than simply following trends. Additionally, most vintage pieces have a history or story attached to them. From family heirlooms handed down from generation to generation to unique one-of-a-kind finds from flea markets or antique stores – there is something special about knowing the backstory behind a piece of jewelry.

But how do you make sure that your purchase is worth every penny? Assessing the value of antiques and second-hand items like jewelry takes practice, but fear not – this guide will help you better assess price points in no time!

Here, we’ll cover key elements such as age, condition, and provenance so that you can confidently make judicious investments in collectible items.

What is Vintage Jewelry?

Vintage jewelry is a term used to describe any jewelry that has been around for some time, usually older than 30 years. It is often characterized by intricate designs and craftsmanship and is made from precious materials like gold or silver. Vintage jewelry is typically purchased to collect rather than wear it and can therefore have a higher value than new jewelry. The designs and styles will generally reflect the period in which they were made, including popular design trends such as Art Deco or Edwardian pieces.

Generally speaking, vintage jewelry is precious due to its rarity and craftsmanship; it is considered collectible by many people specializing in fashion history or antique collecting. As such, it can be pretty expensive, depending on the condition and age of the piece(s). However, due to its increasing popularity over the past few decades—particularly amongst vintage clothing enthusiasts—there are now more ways than ever for someone to acquire vintage pieces without breaking their budget.

Vintage vs Antique: What’s the Difference?

Vintage and antique are two terms that can often be used interchangeably, but there is a slight difference in their definitions. Vintage refers to items that are at least 20-100 years old, depending on which field of art or history the particular item comes from. Generally speaking, vintage items come from the 1920s-1960s era, with designs influenced by previous decades as well. Antique refers specifically to items from more than 100 years ago—typically things created before the early 1900s—and is generally reserved for collectible objects such as furniture or artwork.

And when it comes to jewelry, vintage jewelry is typically defined as pieces made between the 1920s and 1980s. At the same time, antique jewelry refers to any piece older than 100 years old and is more likely to have been crafted using traditional techniques instead of modern manufacturing processes.

How To Determine the Value of Vintage Jewelry

Determining the value of vintage jewelry can be a tricky task, as many factors have to be taken into consideration. The piece’s age, condition, and rarity are all important elements that will affect its overall worth.

Step 1: Identify

If you are curious about the vintage status of a piece of jewelry, look back to where and when it was acquired. If purchased from a flea market, antique shop or estate sale, there is good potential for authenticity as vintage pieces – those 20 years old or older. Also, consider if its style falls within certain time periods, including art deco, retro-style mid-20th century jewels from the 70s and 80s, and clues like symbol stamps could help identify your piece as authentic vintage jewelry!

Step 2: Examine

When assessing the worth of vintage jewelry, close examination, and careful observation are absolutely critical. In addition, appreciate any semblance of workmanship or craftsmanship; highly intricate pieces likely to have been created by hand will certainly be more valuable than those made via large-scale manufacturing processes that proliferated during the mid 20th century. Check out the hallmarks! Most vintage jewelry pieces I have encountered often always had hallmarks engraved in the jewelry. Nevertheless, it’s important to note that mass-produced antique items can still hold significant value – a great deal of jewelry from the 1940s and 1950s was manufactured on an industrial scale!

Step 3: Research

If you’re looking to value your collection of vintage and antique jewelry, getting online is a great first step! There are several reliable resources that can help come up with an estimate. Research on the provenance of the vintage jewelry you’re eyeing. Additionally, familiarizing yourself with the process by using a jewelry identification guide will get you off on the right foot. You can also go to a jewelry store like W. Villarica Jewelry for a piece of more accurate information.

Read More: How Much is My Jewelry Worth? 4 Ways to Estimate Jewelry Value

Schedule an Appointment Today

Looking to get an appraisal for your valuable items?
Schedule an appointment today for a fair and accurate assessment!

Factors Affecting Jewelry Value

When it comes to factors affecting jewelry value, vintage pieces can often be worth the most. Vintage jewelry refers to any piece of jewelry that is 20 years or older, and it generally has a higher resale value compared to more modern pieces.

Craftsmanship quality

The quality of craftsmanship employed in creating the jewelry is also a key factor impacting its market value – higher quality workmanship will result in pieces that look more impressive and thus be worth more money. Furthermore, how intricate a piece of jewelry is can influence its price point; additional details like patterns or even engravings take longer to add to the desirability of an item – affecting its resale potential as demand increases.


The metals used to craft jewelry will determine its overall value. Precious metals such as gold, silver, and platinum are highly valued for their durability and longevity, making them more expensive than alternative metal options like brass or copper. In addition to the type of metal used in the jewelry’s construction, its purity (measured in Karat) will also play a role in its value.


When specific pieces are rarer than others, they become more valuable due to scarcity – even if they aren’t considered particularly beautiful compared to other options with higher price points. For instance, vintage jewelry can hold a lot of sentimental/marketable value because it reflects an era or period often not seen any more today. Or collectible items from reputable designers had sustained their desirability over time due to much smaller production runs when each piece was initially released onto marketplaces.

Beauty and design

Beauty and design are two significant considerations when it comes to factors affecting the value of the jewelry. In addition, jewelry’s aesthetic appeal plays a vital role in its overall worth; pieces designed impeccably, crafted with precision, and featuring high-grade materials or precious stones can command higher prices than mundane designs. Furthermore, certain iconic styles or themes can accrue additional monetary worth due to their cultural or historical significance.


Like any antique or collectible item, the condition is key when determining how much something is worth; scratches, dents, or discoloration can greatly reduce its value, while perfect examples of pieces tend to maintain (or even increase) their inherent worth over time due to their scarcity in good shape.

Related: Beginner’s Guide to Jewelry Investment

Vintage Jewelry Value FAQs

Is vintage costume jewelry worth money?

The short answer is that vintage costume jewelry can be worth money, depending on factors such as the designer, condition, age, and rarity.

Vintage costume jewelry usually falls into two categories: high-end designer pieces made by renowned designers like Christian Dior or Coco Chanel; and long-running lines manufactured by large companies such as Swarovski or Empire Mfg. Both items are likely to retain some value if they’re well-maintained.

Read More:

Is vintage jewelry more valuable?

While some vintage jewelry may be more expensive than its contemporary counterparts, not all are more valuable. To determine whether a piece of vintage jewelry is more practical, you must first consider its age, condition, and provenance.

Reach out to Willyn Villarica Jewelry

Many factors must be considered when appraising vintage jewelry. However, with the right research and these helpful tips, you can get a good idea of what your piece is worth. If you need assistance assessing the value of your jewelry, 

Willyn Villarica is your trusted partner for vintage jewelry appraisal services, catering to clients around the globe. Our expertise and commitment to excellence ensure accurate and reliable assessments of your precious gemstones. It’s important to note that while we offer our services worldwide, clients are responsible for covering all travel expenses. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to have your diamonds expertly graded by Willyn Villarica.  Willyn Villarica Jewelry would be glad to help. Our professional staff has years of experience in the industry and would love to add another beautiful piece to our extensive collection.

To request information or schedule appointments, please feel free to contact us via email at admin@willynvillaricajewelry.com, you may also connect with us through our official Facebook (Willyn Villarica Jewelry) and Instagram (@willynvillarica_jewelry) accounts. Should you require immediate assistance, we are also accessible for direct communication at +63279497547.

  • Willyn Villarica

    Willyn Villarica, a third-generation jeweler from the Philippines, brings a wealth of expertise to the world of gemology and jewelry appraisal. As a licensed Graduate Gemologist, accredited by the prestigious Gemological Institute of America, she is not only a master of her craft but also holds the distinction of being the first Filipino member of the National Associ...

Leave a Comment